Rick,
Pardon the top post.
Perhaps I should have said, does the list have the functionality to send
messages? I seem to recall there were some issues with it when I created
it. Mailman3 has not been a trivial experience IMHO.
I created a test list and it seemed to work better. I am pretty sure
that there are some issues with the existing list. I will have to
investigate. I was happy to get some at least "working". Although,
I would think that would be the impetus for making it work correctly
rather than continue on half configured.
I appreciate the TODO list below.
Brian
On Mon, Sep 26, 2022 at 11:02:45PM -0700, Rick Moen wrote:
Quoting Brian E. Lavender (brian(a)brie.com):
I applied security updates to the server and I
just want to make sure it
still works.
Looks good-ish.
Reviewing stuff I raised in March about the then-state of Mailman3
(which hosts this iteration of lug-nuts):
Point 1: Brian, maybe you should add one of those URLs (maybe the
postorius one) to the standard footer applied to postings by Mailman.
IMO, that was a very useful default feature of Mailman2.
Status: The footer remains...
_______________________________________________
Lug-nuts mailing list -- lug-nuts(a)bigbrie.com
To unsubscribe send an email to lug-nuts-leave(a)bigbrie.com
...stuck at Mailman3-default, with indication of how to navigate to
postorius[1] (Mailman3's replacement for Mailman2's listinfo page). No
indication of how to get to hyperkitty[1] (Mailman3's replacement for
Mailman2's pipermail HTML archiver). Mailman2's standard footer pointed
to the mailing list's listinfo page (which then linked to other stuff,
which is also true of Mailman3's postorius).
You _could_ alter the default footer to make it useful to subscribers.
The default one, telling subscribers the list's name, its posting
address, and the e-mail address for unsubscribing isn't very useful.
Why not add a postorius link?
Point 2: On the postorius page, I notice there's no link for
subscribers to view the membership roster, as there was on the
corresponding Mailman2 listinfo page. Brian, is that public-facing
feature just totally gone? Is there a way to switch it back on?
The postorius page _still_ provides no access to the subscriber roster.
Brian, is that public-facing feature (member-accessible membership
roster) just totally gone? Seriously, sir. I saw in my subscriber
options a reference to it, here:
"Hide address ( ) Yes (o) No
When someone views the list membership, your email address is normally
shown (in an obscured fashion to thwart spam harvesters). If you do not
want your email address to show up on this membership roster at all,
select Yes for this option."
So, that _speaks_ of persons' ability to view the list membership --
but where? Brian, have you perhaps disabled subscriber ability to
view the roster, in the mailing list's configuration? If so, would
you revise that, please?
Point 3: [...]
This was about subscription options, and the "Log In" button. This
evening, paying closer attention, I see that Mailman3 has a new notion
of creating an "account" on
bigbrie.com, and associating that with a
subscribed e-mail address. I've done that, and successfully logged in.
This then gives access to per-subscriber options, such as delivery
status enabled/disabled. Win!
So, point 3 is done.
Point 4: On the
https://bigbrie.com/mailman3/hyperkitty/list/lug-nuts@bigbrie.com/
archives page, _yesterday_ when I tried to drill down to individual
archived threads and postings, I got HTTP errors.
Today, no HTTP errors. Smooth sailing. Point 4, done!
Point 5: Any chance you can get the pre-Feb. 28, 2022 mailing list
archive from Roberto Leibman, and import it into the Mailman3 history?
Hyperkitty is still missing the entire mailing list history prior to 28
Feb 2022. Brian, I'm _sure_ Mailman3 has a way to import cumulative
mbox files (pipermail's backing store).
Point 6: Also, time stamps for postings in _UTC_? Really?
(Perhaps this weird default can be corrected?)
Today, I notice that, yes, hyperkitty does display messages with
timestamps in UTC, _but_ if you hover over the date, you see a shadow
display of "Sender's time: [actual timestamp]".
So, it seems like this weirdness of UTC-default-display is a deliberate
decision of the Mailman3/hyperkitty coders. Ugh.
Separately, I'll confess that I'm one of the many people who find the
design and layout of the hyperkitty archiver quite horrible: It
give the impression of being dumbed-down for smartphone viewing,
e.g., no real headers, doesn't even display entire postings
without clicky-clicky, and people's e-mail addresses are hidden
completely.
I'm also pretty disenchanted with the rest of Mailman3, too, frankly,
though I now understand the UI a little better. The experience has
inclined me to _not_ migrate any of the existing Mailman2 lists I
administer to Mailman3. When Mailman2 becomes too crufty, I'll need to
find some other way to move sideways to something else. God help me,
maybe even ezmlm.
[1] As a reminder:
postorius:
https://bigbrie.com/mailman3/postorius/lists/lug-nuts.bigbrie.com/
hyperkitty:
https://bigbrie.com/mailman3/hyperkitty/list/lug-nuts@bigbrie.com/
(Note that once one has navigated to postorious, there's an archive
(hyperkitty) link from there.
(I re-found those links from my saved copy of my previous posting, but,
have to say, they're not really easy to find, generally. That's why
a footer breadcrumb would help.)
_______________________________________________
Lug-nuts mailing list -- lug-nuts(a)bigbrie.com
To unsubscribe send an email to lug-nuts-leave(a)bigbrie.com
"There are two ways of constructing a software design. One way is to
make it so simple that there are obviously no deficiencies. And the other
way is to make it so complicated that there are no obvious deficiencies."
Professor C. A. R. Hoare
The 1980 Turing award lecture